Petoskey Stone Media Inc. Review: A Digital Marketing Agency with Mixed Results

Introduction

Petoskey Stone Media Inc. is a hybrid advertising agency based in Port Huron, Michigan, specializing in digital marketing, social media management, SEO, SEM, website design, content marketing, and traditional advertising. They also offer graphic design, photography, and marketing consulting services, catering primarily to clients in the Great Lakes region.

With a broad range of services, they aim to help businesses enhance their online presence and marketing strategies. However, customer experiences vary—some praise their ability to grow social media followings, while others criticize their workflow and service quality.

Pros and Cons of Petoskey Stone Media Inc.

Social Media Growth & Engagement ✅

One client reported significant success in Facebook growth, gaining 10,000 followers over an 8-year period. Additionally, their Google My Business page saw over 1,600 comments in just two weeks, indicating strong engagement.

Customer Verdict:

• "They helped grow my Facebook presence significantly."
• "The engagement on my Google page was impressive."

Workflow & Communication Issues ❌

A major complaint revolves around poor workflow management and lack of collaboration. One client bluntly stated:

"Not existent."

This suggests that Petoskey Stone Media may struggle with client communication and project coordination, leading to frustration.

Customer Verdict:

• "There was no real workflow between us and their team."

Quality of Work: A Polarizing Experience ⚠️

While some clients see results, others feel the work is sloppy and inferior. One dissatisfied customer remarked:

"They are able to get people to pay for inferior and sloppy work."

This raises concerns about consistency in service quality—some campaigns may succeed, while others fall short.

Customer Verdict:

• "The quality doesn’t always match the price."
• "Results are hit or miss."

Areas for Improvement 🔄

When asked what could be done better, one client suggested:

"No, outside of hiring another media group or doing it in-house."

This implies that some clients feel outsourcing to a different agency or handling marketing internally might be a better solution than continuing with Petoskey Stone Media.

Final Verdict: Should You Hire Petoskey Stone Media Inc.?

Strengths

✔ Effective social media growth (10k+ Facebook followers, high Google engagement)
✔ Broad service offerings (SEO, SEM, web design, content marketing, photography)

Weaknesses

❌ Poor workflow & communication (lack of collaboration reported)
❌ Inconsistent quality (some clients feel work is sloppy or overpriced)

Who Should Consider Them?

• Businesses looking for social media growth
• Those needing a one-stop-shop for digital marketing

Who Should Look Elsewhere?

• Clients who prioritize strong communication & structured workflows
• Businesses expecting consistently high-quality deliverables

Conclusion: A Mixed Bag with Potential

Petoskey Stone Media Inc. delivers strong social media results for some clients but struggles with workflow transparency and service consistency. If you’re willing to take a chance and closely monitor their work, they might be worth considering. However, if you need reliable, high-touch collaboration, exploring other agencies or in-house solutions may be the better route.

Final Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) – Decent for growth, but communication and quality concerns remain.