LeadsNearby Review: A Digital Marketing Partner That Actually Gets Local Contractors

As a small business owner in the home services industry, I’ve seen my fair share of marketing agencies promising the moon—only to deliver vague reports and underwhelming results. That’s why working with LeadsNearby felt like a breath of fresh air. They’re a full-service digital marketing agency that specializes in helping local contractors like me grow their businesses, and they actually get what we need: more qualified leads, stronger local visibility, and a brand that stands out in a crowded market.

Here’s how my experience with them played out—and why they might be the right fit for other contractors tired of generic marketing strategies.

1. Full-Circle Marketing That Actually Works

Most agencies focus on one thing—SEO, ads, or social media—and call it a day. LeadsNearby takes a 360-degree approach, which was a game-changer for my business. They didn’t just tweak my Google My Business profile and disappear; they helped me:

• Define my brand voice (turns out, "trusted local expert" works better than "cheapest in town").
• Optimize my local search presence (I started ranking for terms I didn’t even know customers were searching for).
• Run targeted ad campaigns that actually brought in calls, not just clicks.

The best part? They didn’t treat me like just another client. Their team took time to understand my business, my competition, and my long-term goals before rolling out a strategy.

2. Local SEO That Puts You on the Map (Literally)

If you’re a contractor, you need to show up when homeowners search for services in your area. LeadsNearby’s local SEO expertise was hands-down their strongest asset.

Within a few months, my business started appearing in the local 3-pack (those top three listings on Google Maps) for key terms like "roofing repair near me." They also cleaned up my online listings, ensuring my name, address, and phone number were consistent everywhere—something I didn’t even realize was hurting my rankings.

One minor critique? The initial setup took a little longer than expected, but the results were worth the wait.

3. Ads That Convert (Not Just Drain Budgets)

I’ve wasted money on Google Ads before—spending hundreds for a handful of leads that never panned out. LeadsNearby’s approach was different.

Instead of blasting ads everywhere, they:

• Targeted hyper-local areas (neighborhoods where my services were in demand).
• Used lead-tracking calls-to-action (so I knew which ads were actually driving calls).
• Optimized based on real data, not guesses.

The difference was night and day. My cost per lead dropped, and the leads were higher quality—homeowners ready to hire, not just window shoppers.

Pros & Cons at a Glance

What I Loved:

✔ True local marketing expertise—they understand contractors, not just theory.
✔ Holistic strategy—SEO, ads, branding, and reputation management all working together.
✔ Transparent reporting—no confusing jargon, just clear metrics on what’s working.
✔ Better lead quality—fewer tire-kickers, more serious customers.

What Could Be Improved:

✖ Initial setup takes time—not a "quick fix" agency (but good marketing rarely is).
✖ Higher price point than DIY options—but you get what you pay for in results.

Final Thoughts: A Partner, Not Just Another Vendor

LeadsNearby isn’t for every business—if you’re looking for cheap, generic marketing, you’ll find plenty of options. But if you’re a local contractor serious about growing your business, they deliver where it counts: real leads, real visibility, and real authority in your market.

They’re not perfect (no agency is), but they’re one of the few that actually make digital marketing feel worth the investment.