Idea Peddler Review: A Full-Service Advertising Agency That Delivers Results

Introduction

Idea Peddler is a full-service advertising agency specializing in helping conscientious clients drive growth and create brand shifts. With a focus on design, production, media planning, PR, and social media, they leverage top-tier talent and tools to deliver impactful marketing solutions. Their mission? "Doing good work for nice people."

But does Idea Peddler live up to its promises? Let’s dive into real customer experiences to uncover the agency’s strengths, weaknesses, and overall performance.

Pros of Idea Peddler

1. Exceptional Creative & Strategic Approach

Clients consistently praise Idea Peddler for their innovative and artistic vision, setting them apart from competitors.

"Their creative spirit and enthusiasm for their work match their impressive technical skills. They don't just know how to create a quality video—their fresh, current, and artistic eye definitely distinguishes them."

Another client highlighted their holistic marketing approach:

"They looked at us and our market as a continuum, part of a larger whole. They did exactly what we were trying to do but didn’t know how."

2. Strong Project Management & Communication

Efficient workflows and clear communication are recurring themes in client feedback.

"With weekly status update meetings, the workflow has been quite effective. The Idea Peddler team communicates clearly and generally over-delivers on projects that are on time and within budget."

One client appreciated their responsiveness and adaptability:

"They were incredibly responsive, informative, and flexible given our evolving business goals, new retail openings, and budget fluctuation."

3. Measurable Results & ROI

Several clients reported tangible success metrics, from increased engagement to direct sales conversions.

"IP's social media leadership increased our followers, post engagement, and, in certain business areas, translated into direct sales conversion."

Another noted:

"Throughout our campaigns, we consistently drove lower CPMs and higher direct response rates month over month."

4. Client-Centric & Collaborative

Idea Peddler fosters strong relationships, often feeling like an extension of their clients’ teams.

"The IP team is kind, courageous, and truly felt like a part of our in-house team. They bring expertise and compassion to their work."

A different client added:

"They were very clear communicators. In fact, they helped keep us on point and on track, which was enormously helpful."

Cons of Idea Peddler

1. Occasional Account Management Shifts

A few clients mentioned sudden changes in account contacts, though transparency helped mitigate concerns.

"We had one change in account contact that was rather sudden. Cimin was transparent and approached the change with care."

2. Geographic Limitations for Localized Campaigns

For clients in niche markets, distance could be a minor hurdle.

"Idea Peddler is in Texas, and we’re in New Mexico. They know New Mexico, but they’re not here every day. You have to adjust for the difference in location."

3. Premium Pricing (But Worth It)

While not a universal complaint, one client advised:

"Make sure you have a good budget. Don’t nickel and dime the cost—be prepared to pay it gladly."

Final Verdict

Strengths:

✅ Creative & strategic excellence
✅ Strong project management & communication
✅ Proven ROI & measurable success
✅ Client-focused & collaborative

Weaknesses:

⚠️ Occasional account management shifts
⚠️ Geographic limitations for hyper-local campaigns
⚠️ Higher budget requirements (but justified by results)

Conclusion: Is Idea Peddler Worth It?

Based on overwhelmingly positive feedback, Idea Peddler stands out as a high-performing, client-centric agency that delivers real business impact. While minor hiccups exist (like contact transitions), their strategic expertise, creativity, and results-driven approach make them a top choice for brands serious about growth.

Final Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)

Best For: Businesses seeking full-service marketing with measurable ROI and a collaborative partner.

Not Ideal For: Those with very tight budgets or needing hyper-local, in-person agency presence.

Ready to elevate your brand? Check out Idea Peddler at www.ideapeddler.com.