Earthy Creative Review: Storytelling Excellence for Brands

Earthy Creative, founded by Todd Prodanovich, is a content creation and storytelling agency specializing in crafting compelling narratives for brands of all sizes. With Todd’s background as the former editor-in-chief of Surfer Magazine, Earthy Creative blends journalistic storytelling with marketing expertise to produce engaging content—from blog posts to ad videos—for clients like Patagonia and environmental nonprofits.

The agency prides itself on understanding brand voices quickly, delivering high-quality work efficiently, and maintaining a professional yet personable approach.

Pros of Earthy Creative

1. Exceptional Storytelling & Creativity

Clients consistently praise Todd’s ability to "get" their brand instantly. One reviewer noted:

"Todd just 'got us' right away. He really went the extra mile to create a top-notch product."

Another highlighted the "fantastic video that we love!", emphasizing the agency’s knack for blending creativity with marketing effectiveness.

2. Strong Engagement & Impact

Earthy Creative’s content doesn’t just look good—it performs. A client shared:

"Amazing engagement when we linked to our social media, it sits on the front of our website!"

This demonstrates the agency’s ability to create shareable, high-impact content that resonates with audiences.

3. Professional & Pleasant Collaboration

Clients describe Todd as "down to earth yet extremely professional." Communication is seamless, whether through in-person meetings, virtual calls, or email. One reviewer mentioned:

"They were perfectly prompt and communicative. They also ensured quality and on-time delivery."

4. Efficiency Without Compromising Quality

Despite fast turnarounds, Earthy Creative maintains high standards:

"Todd was efficient with our time yet delivered amazing results."

This balance is rare in creative agencies, where rushed projects often lead to diluted quality.

Cons of Earthy Creative

1. Limited Availability (Potential Bottleneck)

Since Todd is the primary storyteller, scaling could be a challenge for larger projects. However, no clients have reported delays—just a consideration for brands needing large-scale content production.

2. Niche Expertise (Not for Every Industry)

While Earthy Creative excels in environmental and outdoor brands (thanks to Todd’s Surfer Magazine background), businesses outside these niches haven’t been reviewed yet. It’s unclear how adaptable the storytelling is for, say, tech or finance sectors.

Final Verdict: A Top-Tier Storytelling Partner

Earthy Creative shines in authentic storytelling, engagement-driven content, and client collaboration. Clients repeatedly emphasize Todd’s ability to understand their brand deeply while delivering on time and with creativity.

Best for:

• Eco-conscious brands
• Outdoor and lifestyle companies
• Nonprofits needing compelling narratives

Potential Limitations:

• Solo-founder structure may limit scalability
• Less proven in highly technical industries

If you need high-impact content with a personal touch, Earthy Creative is a stellar choice. As one client perfectly summed it up:

"None. We are so pleased!"